Why does .glassEffect(.clear) look frosted in my macOS app?

This is the one I'm working on:

This is from the ChatGPT app, which works fine:

I've been asking chatGPT, but it can’t figure out where the problem is.

Hello @Phupha

Are you able to provide more information? I see the frosted effect you are talking about, I want to confirm if this is a result of the new Liquid Glass slider or if what we are seeing can be resolved with code.

macOS 27 Golden gate adds and a new slider lets you customize how Liquid Glass looks, from ultra-clear to fully tinted. I'm curious if adjusting this slider can achieve the result you are expecting – if not, can you share the project you are using, and where you see the difference in Liquid Glass? Adjust this in System Settings > Appearance > Liquid Glass.

If you are comparing your code to another third-party app, keep in mind we can't confirm exactly how they achieved a goal, but if you share what you have started and the direction you are looking to go in, I and others can chime in 😀

If what we are seeing can be resolved with code, or should be filed as feedback – I'd like to help.
 Travis

I created two minimal samples using the same Liquid Glass code.

The left one is inside a transparent, borderless floating panel (frosted).
The right one is inside a normal SwiftUI window (clear).

They look different even though the .glassEffect(.clear, ...) code is the same. I also tried changing the Liquid Glass slider in System Settings. It changes the appearance in other apps, but it does not affect either of my sample versions.